I’ve Outgrown Sarah J Maas

No, this isn’t some salacious post about Sarah J Maas or the ACOTAR series. I’m just over her books and wanted to come on here and talk about why. This post isn’t a drag. This is just a reader who’s grown out of Sarah J Maas and her work.

If you’re new to the fantasy genre, Sarah J Maas is one of those authors people pick up in hopes of finding love in the genre. For the most part, people pick up SJM and gush over the characters, especially the male characters. They love the bad ass females set in these Fae worlds. And for a really long time, I also really loved Sarah J Maas for the same things.

Over the holidays, the cover for A Court of Silver Flames was revealed and while at that point I was really excited about the book, I wasn’t too excited for the cover. It didn’t match the covers of the past three books, but matches the new covers set out for them. So I could get a copy of this book, but would probably have to buy the rest of the series in the new covers to match. You know the bookshelf aesthetic; every book in a series must match.

But truthfully, it doesn’t matter what the cover looks like because we get a new book in the series, right? And while I was waiting for the newest story, I read Crescent City as well as numerous other fantasy novels over the course of 2020. I thought Crescent City was wildly entertaining filled with characters you’ll love and a story that keeps moving for all 800 pages of that chonker. But there was a waning feeling; a sense that perhaps SJM doesn’t speak to me as much as she used to.

And I love seeing folks picking up her books for the first time. I love seeing people who don’t normally read fantasy books find something of interest in her books. But something happened to me between finishing Crescent City, seeing the cover for A Court of Silver Flames, and everything in between. My love for SJM wanes a little everyday and my interest in her new book isn’t as much as it used to be.

At this point in my life, I’ve read some great fantasy books that I would much rather read than SJM’s books. Perhaps what I’m feeling is that I’m growing up and some of the books that I loved when I was younger will be fondly remembered, but no longer followed closely. I’ll most definitely appreciate SJM for writing some great stories that thrust me into the YA fantasy world. I appreciate the fact that she’s written something digestible with characters worth investing your time and energy into and keeping me on my toes from book to book to book. But it’s time to finally put her away, read other books, and find other worlds beyond this one. Because like many parts of our lives, our reading lives are ever evolving journeys between worlds. We grow tired of one and then move onto the next one with great respect for the books that got us here. You can say I’m setting off into the sherbert-colored sunset tipping my hat to the author who started off my love for fantasy.

Again, I’m not hating on SJM and the folks who absolutely love this series and her books. I encourage everyone to pick up this book, but what I’ve concluded after writing this post is that I’ve outgrown her work. I’ve moved beyond Sarah J Maas to other authors that I want to put my effort into.

10 thoughts on “I’ve Outgrown Sarah J Maas

  1. It’s an interesting post! I happens a lot more than we think it does. It is 100% normal to outgrow authors. Some books I read as a middle-grader I wouldn’t read as an adult (I tried and I cringed so hard at the writing). It’s just part of growing up, and leaves space for us to discover new favorites 🙂


  2. I outgrew her books as well. She has a certain writing style that isn’t for me. I thought it would change in ACoSF. I read a chapter preview and apparently she still writes that way. I also don’t find any of her characters relatable. All of them are gorgeous, rich, and immortal. There’s no real flaws with them so I can’t connect. I feel SJM has a certain aesthetic and stuck with it. That’s fine if it’s what works for her but I’ve moved on. There’s so much more creative storytelling out there that speaks to me.


  3. I think we all have authors whose work we outgrow, and that’s OK. Our preferences change, and there should be no shame in that 🙂


  4. I’m not as excited about the book as I thought I was going to be, which is a little concerning. I feel as though her stories have a particular formula and although there are differences in all of them they are fundamentally the same.

    I love her books at the moment, but I can definitely see why you would outgrow them.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. yes! her stories do have a formula and there are certain tropes she uses that bug me, but yeah. i’ve somehow moved on from her work. I’ll probably read her in the future, but not as dire to do it as before


  5. I love this post! While I never was super into Sarah J Maas myself, I can respect her for the community she has built through her stories. I have felt this way about other popular authors like Cassandra Clare where I can appreciate what they did for me but also know that I am not at a point where I enjoy those types of stories.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. I loved reading your thoughts on this! I totally can see how people outgrow her writing style and move on to new authors they’ve discovered and fallen in love with. Even recently reading ACOSF, I’ve noticed things that I don’t love about her writing, which I never would’ve expected because I’ve been such a fan for awhile now. I think the topic of outgrowing authors and writing is really interesting in general, and it’s always nice when we as readers recognize when we’re ready to move on and explore other things that might click better! ♥

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Exactly! It’s not a complete write off. I have a feeling some time down the line I’ll definitely pick this one up, but it’s not as dire for me to read it as it used to be. I love that authors help to shape the kind of worlds you like to read, but I also love that you can let them go when you’re done with them too.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. This is interesting! I’m thinking of getting into her. I almost never read YA, but given the rave reviews she has, I thought I’d give it a shot. I read the first Crescent City and I enjoyed that.

    That being said I do know what you mean by outgrowing authors. I have definitely done that with Roald Dahl’s children’s stories, which I loved reading but I find I can’t immerse myself in anymore.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s